Hi Lee,
Yes that is rather disappointing that the starter motor is being difficult. Do you know for certain that TDC on the pulley actually corresponds with #1 piston actually being at TDC? Reason I ask is that Rover was less that accurate on more than one occasion when it came to this, and while some pulleys will have TDC where it should be, many won't. So if your TDC marking is actually advanced of that, then all the markings will be out, so 12 degrees BTDC might actually be 20 degrees BTDC purely as an example. This would certainly impact on the starter motor's ability to turn the engine over.
What were the timing marks showing when the engine speed plateaued?
I am pleased to know though that it did indeed make a difference, and that there was an improvement..
Ron.